Knock-Down Arguments

Alexander Paulsen While reading TIME magazine I stumbled upon an interesting article1 about how kids that get spanked grow up to be more aggressive. Apparently children solve problems by mimicking their parents behaviour and not by listening to what they say — who could have guessed?

Groundbreaking as this insight might be for the average psychology student, it leaves an interesting question — What is the right way to teach children?2

Any method applied should not only stop the child from acting in an unwanted way, it should also set a positive example on how adults are supposed to solve these problems themselves. This raises a much bigger question for me:

How are adults supposed find a consensus, if one party is not willing to listen to logical arguments?3

How do I argue with someone that tells me my point of view is invalid, without giving me any reason? How do I break through that thick skull, without actually breaking it, or damaging the relationship in some other way?

A passive aggressive approach seems to work great, but it will poison a relationship really fast.4 So lately I find myself more and more drawn to the japanese way. Smile, nod and just avoid that person. If I can’t talk rationally with a friend, why talk at all and if I don’t talk why is he still my friend?

But I still wonder isn’t there a better way?


  1. C Taylor, J. Manganello, S. Lee, J. Rice. Pediatrics, Apr 2010 

  2. Don’t worry I’m not thinking about getting children anytime soon. I just find it easier to treat other adults like children when they misbehave. 

  3. I should probably watch political debates, but there is little that bores me more than current politics. 

  4. Also would you use passive aggressive methods with children? 


8 Responses to Knock-Down Arguments

  1. 963 Julia 2010-04-14 11:22

    Any actual, current event/reason that triggered this entry?

  2. 964 Julia 2010-04-14 11:22

    Besides the article, that is…

  3. 965 alexander 2010-04-15 7:59

    I got this question so often now — some people even called me to ask :P

    Nothing big really. A few completely unrelated events, but none of them caused more than a shoulder shrug.

  4. 966 Julia 2010-04-16 11:12

    :)

    (Glad to hear)

  5. 967 Julia 2010-04-21 10:26

    Noch eine Frage (hat lange gedauert):

    Bis du die kleine Zwiderwurzen auf dem Bild?

  6. 968 alexander 2010-04-21 11:35

    Zwiderwurz =O

    Aber ja der fesche junge Herr auf dem Bild bin ich :)
    Hast du meinen hervorstechenden Wirbel am Hinterkopf nicht erkannt? Den hassen die Frisöre noch immer :P

  7. 969 Julia 2010-04-21 11:49

    Nett! :)
    (also, entweder du schaust zwider drein, oder du planst gerade den Ausbruch aus der Gehschule und musst grad sehr scharf nachdenken.)

  8. 970 alexander 2010-04-21 18:02

    Angeblich habe ich da versucht meinen Großvater davon zu überzeugen, dass er doch ein Feuer für mich anzünden soll.

    Neben Wolken, oder dem Himmel allgemein, wohl das faszinierendste was es gibt :P



About

"But I don't want to go among mad people," Alice remarked.
"Oh, you can't help that," said the Cat: "we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad."
"How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice.
"You must be," said the Cat, "or you wouldn't have come here."

User

Remember me on this computer?